Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kathleen Lowrey's avatar

Wonderful protest, brava.

The reason it is so important to people that these athletes are "not trans" is because they know when they are lying about trans identified men they are just flat out lying on purpose. It does make them uncomfortable, at some level, to do that.

So it feels really good to them to crusade on behalf of these boxers without the ick of politically motivated lying. It really makes them feel super self-righteous about the rightness of their cause, they think: I can't believe you TERFs are mad at me even over THIS.

Of course for us terfs we just really are concerned with biological sex, so to us these cases are not importantly different. A man is entering women's space.

My mom forwarded an email from a friend of hers that included an explanation by a biologist (a prof at UNC-Asheville) that was "really clear". It was all the bafflegab about how things like Klinefelter's Syndrome mean sex is a spectrum and that anyway you don't have to totally understand all the intricacies of complex biology to be kind! All you have to do is know that is Complicated and also Be Kind!

(My mom is not fooled by this for a minute, but her friend clearly is)

Then there was the CBC journalist who opened his thinkpiece telling us we needed to concentrate on the 'actual protagonist' of the story: Khelif. In other words, if you just remind yourself of the eternal verity that women are emotional support animals for stories where men are the heroes, everything about how you should feel and respond to this situation falls into place!

Finally, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar today had a piece about how this is a story about people being mean to "two women" (the two boxers). So in his version, these are women who don't conform to society's expectations of womanhood and thus to be a Number One Cool Male Feminist (who has slept with 20k women by his own account) you need to lecture everyone else to relax and be cool about it.

I think the first example is someone who wants to be sophisticated and "kind". I think the second example is someone who does viscerally get that these are men, but *for that reason* hasn't looked into it any further to understand it better. The third example is someone who wants to be cool.

These are motivated misunderstandings but they aren't examples of "I know these guys are male and I am going to lie about it on purpose". I actually wonder if the Olympic situation is going to be bad for the TRA side in the long run, because many "allies" have found it such a delight to argue these instances and they may remember that feeling when they are back to arguing Lia Thomas style examples, which give you much less sciencey sounding self righteous bafflegab to work with.

Expand full comment
Emily S.'s avatar

"The female category will end up an internal-testicle fest." Lol - brilliant! But sadly also the very probable, horrible scenario that is laid out now. Thank you, brave women, for taking the fight heroically to the streets of Paris! We will not let this injustice to women stand

Expand full comment
38 more comments...

No posts